Armenian Libertarian-Socialist Movement

Global, Caucasian and Armenian politics in anarchist perspective

Reaction in Russophone blobosphere and the Reactionary Mentality

Posted by Sasuntsi Anarchist on March 1, 2007

Well… it looks like my entry noticing the uncanny simirarity between HHK and Nazi insignia and also mentioning Garegin Nzhdeh has caught the attention of Armenian Nazi bloggers (I don’t want to call them “fascists”, though some of the things that they’re saying are quite disturbing and outright fascist).  In the last 24 hours I have been accused of many things: 1) of comparing Nzhdeh to Nietzsche (hmm… where?), 2) of being a pro-American sycophant, 3) of being a Jew, 4) “Safarov” of our nation, 4) of being uneducated, 5) and many-many-many other things.

These are at most 5-7 people.  They take turns agreeing with other, and seemingly dream of a society were everybody would agree with each other, where questioning of Nzhdeh’s works would be strictly forbidden under a penalty of death, where it will be forbidden not to hate everyone who is of Turkish descent.  They also take turns competing as to who will reach the farthest in the Right-wing extremism.

Among these entries you will find proposals to canonize Nzhdeh (i.e. to make him a saint) and to sanctify his works, so that nobody will have the right to criticise or even question his disturbingly Racist ideas.  There are also proposals to kill me, to strangle me, to shit on me, to shoot me and to just simply ignore me.  The most radical of these comments come from Narine (she must be the 100 year old lady with AK-47; from angel-xiligan), then there is ahousekeeper (the one with a marine smiley) and also from Pigh (Tigran K.). 

These discourses and comments are not just simply blog entries.  They are reflexive of the general modus operandi of the broader political discourse in Armenia today.  If you say something against the sanctified paradigm, you will get death threats, which are not just empty words: journalists are being killed or beaten, intellectuals are being threatened, there are very strict Statist taboos on cultural and artistic expression.  You are not allowed not only to step out of the box of “The Normal” “Նորմալ”, but you are not allowed to even think outside of it.  There’s an obvious hypocrisy and opportunism when Armenian right-wing condemn Hrant Dink’s murder – a man who was a courageous speaker, a Parrhesiastes,  in the face of one of the most restrictive regimes near Europe.  But why point fingers and not look at ourselves?  If you choose to step outside of the Rabiz culture your life in Armenia will get tough – gone are the vibrant days when Yerevan and Armenia as a whole was sporting free-thought, free-artistry, free mentality — when culture was not state-controlled, when culture was boiling and people were properly political.  Today you have to be Normal, in order to survive in Armenia: and “normal” means living within the narrowly defined margins within which only the underclass Rabiz and middle-class pseudo-liberal is permitted, while all other alternatives proposing Respect, People-Power, Intellectualism and Solidarity are violently excluded.

Pigh says “Как таковой оппозиции у нас нет, кто есть, себя дискредитировал,а свежей независимой массы не наблюдается.
Власть я тоже не люблю. Ка уже выразился где-то, имею счастье работать в сельских местностях Армении и напрямую вижу,что творится вне Еревана. Это ужасно,ужасен беспредел некоторых олигархов и местных царьков,ужасен уровень коррупции,ужасен цинизм по отношению к народу и ужасен народ,который за 5000 драм или мешок муки с благодарностью избирает этих мразей. Что делать? Не знаю,честно не знаю.. Бороться? С кем? Как?
Для себя я выбрал другой путь,самому пробиваться по жизни и помогать,как только возможно,нашему народу”  Well, maybe in principle we and many other people want the same thing, but where do you get the arrogance to discredit other people’s oppinions regarding the methods of achieving the better conditions of life. It is this exclusionist logic of violently silencing everyone who slightly disagrees with you (so similar to the way that the dominant politicians work) – that will not get us anywhere.  Armenia would benefit a great deal if it heard some of the alternative (and not oppositionist) voices that are coming from within even the poorest strata of our society.   

Sooner or later these people who pride themselves as “Nazis” will need to understand that Armenia is not exclusively their country.  That they are not the only people who are patriots; that other forms of patriotism, which are not necessarily Nzhdeh-esque racist, also exist; that to love your country, to be a good Christian and a good family-man, does not necessarily translate into voting for the fascist HHK or the Nazi Dashnaks; that it is precisely your narrow-minded mentality that is sinking the country into oblivion and poses a very real national-security threat.  Many people are departing from Armenia leaving a brain-drain behind not primarily because of the economic conditions, but precisely because of this fascist and exclusivist atmosphere that is prevalent in our society.  And until it stops, even dual citizenships won’t help to repopulate it – it will keep degenerating into barbarism like with Afghanistan’s Taliban, until the Last Man on his way out will switch off the light.  All I can do at this stage is to ask you, and even to beg you, to Think Deeper!!! 

Ultimately, the Fascist is not at the top, who must be deposed, but he is within us.  The first Revolution that must take place is within the Individual – within each and every one of us.  Until that day when each one of us supersedes the slave mentality encoded into us by the powers that be.  Until that day the soil in Armenia will keep crumbling and the Little Mher will not come back!!!        

As Tigran “Pigh”  himself declares on his “Nothing else matters” blog, he is a National-Socialist a “Nazi” (but not a fascist) and he intends to vote for Dashnaks 2 times in a row (though from his previous entries I though that he is a type who would vote for Henchanks or Marxists or even ՀԿԿ).  And as typical of the general atmosphere of Armenian politics today, Pigh goes on to review the individuals in opposition basing his analysis on the extent of their charisma (something that, as Max Weber argued, is typical of dictatorial societies), rather then as an intellectually engaged analysis of their proposals (though, I have to say there is, indeed, little to review on intellectual level).  For instance, he criticises Shavarsh Kocharian for highlighting El Presidente’s illegitimacy in the European Parliament – Pigh does not contest the illegitimacy of El Presidente, but he says “Стыдно!!!” – Why???  Why not bring out the dirt, the paradoxes and the contradictions, and confront them and deal with them??? Is it because Savarsh’s actions are discounting Armenia’s brand-name and marketing potential??  If Pigh’s argument is not an example of Hypocrisy, then I don’t know what is.  I’m not a big fan of Shavarsh Kocharian either, but there are other more serious reasons pertaining to his proposals and thinking.
And so, it is because of the dominance of these Nazi discourses in Armenian politics, which establish themselves by discursive force of threat and thuggish swearing, physical violence, populist demagoguery, taboo, reductionism, aesthetized fantasies of the Ideal, technocratic thinking about policies, and by forbidding Alternative forces to voice themselves, that contemporary Armenian political thought is still grounded in the 19th century terrains of Herd Mentality.  This is how the questions of “Who is going to lead us?” gain a wider circulations and popular purchase, over the questions of “How can we lead ourselves?” and, “How can people take charge of their collective destiny?

I’m not a Fascist and I believe in Kuhn’s concept of “Open Society” (obviously not is Soros’ interpretation of it).  What I don’t believe in is fascist restrictions and bans, so here are their comments;  Enjoy!

Not surprisingly, all of these Reactionary comments are in the Russophone blogosphere.  The Armenian blogosphere and its politics seems to be reflexive of exactly the type of Russian nationalist Imperialist framing which is in Russia’s and West’s best interests (we saw the same pattern unfolding in Ukraine).  This is how it works:
1) If you are blogging in English then you are a pro-Western, weak, sissy, sly, oppositionist, Jew-influenced Liberal. 
2) If you are blogging in Russian then you are pro-Russian, righteous, truthful, God-fearing Conservative who Knows that everything in Armenia is just perfect and as it should be (apart from minor problems) and that Armenia is on the right track (culminating with EU accession and a society where everybody agrees with each other).

I still like some of the blogs in Armenian.  Though I might not necessarily agree with their views, I’m still open to thought-provoking content and I listen and learn rather then send death-threats.  But if I had a choice, I would be blogging in Latin, Esperanto or Katharevutha (ancient) Greek, or maybe just in Ancient Armenia but then Mokhnavotnuks (Մոխնավոտնուկները) from the Russophone blogosphere might notice my spelling and grammatical “mistakes” in my writing and call me “uneducated” again.    

This is how the cookie crumbles…

Garegin Nzhdeh himself once said «Ամեն ազգում տականք կա, բայց հայ ազգի տականքին ոչ մի այլ տականք չի հասնի»։ (Every nation has its own scum, but Armenian national scum will not compare with the scum of any other nations.) Those taboo-imposing տականք KaGeBesniks, who think they know it all, immediately spring to mind.  In light of the Reactionary nature of the responses to my posting and the extent of its Reactionism, as well as the level of its discourse’s modus operandi, I have to say that on that one Garegin Nzhdeh might have been right… 


19 Responses to “Reaction in Russophone blobosphere and the Reactionary Mentality”

  1. Great post and I agree. Been there, experienced the same, and most recently after interviewing an academic from the Diaspora about the role ethnic Armenians from abroad can play in democratization here.

    90 plus comments including threats of violence, accusations that I might be a Turk, and so on. Like you say, what hypocrites. The same people who shed crocodile tears for Hrant Dink without realizing anything he stood for.

    More ironically, such blindly nationalistic critics, who cannot cope with the idea of individual opinion or anything that bucks the trend of what they’ve been indoctrinated with, are more like those nationalists Turks who killed Dink and others than they care to realize.

    Like you say, it sums up the situation in the Armenian world, and it’s tiring. It’s also why Armenia is getting nowhere. While most countries look inwards to resolve their own problems, we can only look outside to find foreign scapegoats.

    Perhaps the only time Armenians look inside is to weed out anyone different from in among themselves. Incidentally, forget calling these guys Nazis, they are fascists. National Socialists, such as the Dashnaks, can actually discuss and are willing to do so.

    That’s been my experience anyay.

  2. Totally agree. These people if they think deeper will realise that Armenian genocide happened because some Turks thought that Armenians were inferior and need to be purged. Those people are not much different. No surprised that the Dashnaks were in coalition with Young Turks. I am very happy that they were not in the government during the war 1989-94 otherwise they would purge all the Azeri civilians which would cause great resistance, even greater hatred, the world wouldn’t be that favourable towards our cause and we would never be able to win the war. Probably that’s the reason that they were banned on ( it was war time, everybody had access to weapons so I don’t think there was much option) the first place and are still disliked in Armenia. I remember the HAB ( Hayots Azgayin Banak) who were notorious in their barbarity and these were people who collected tons of ammunition in their Armenian cells while there were no weapons in the front lines and those were the people who killed the three very patriot MPs who went to negotiate with them.

  3. nazarian said

    Yes husov em vor Pghi nman mardik Haykakan mentaliteti fringe-n en nerkayacnum. Bayc verjin tas@ tarum nrank kamac-kamac irenc dzerkn en vercnum Hayastani karavarum@. Nrank gortzum en brainwashing-i mijocov (haylur, lratvamijocnerin irenc tri tak anckacnelov) kam el irenc het ch-hamadzaynoghneri fisikakan vochnchacum kam vakhecum (sksatz Artsrun Margaryanic 1998-in verjacratz mi kani shabat arajva lragroghneri mekenaneri hrkizumov).

    Isk ayd nuyn jamanak progressivener@ irar het chen karoghanum lezu gtnel. Barebakhtabar Hanrapetakanner@ mi kich Arevmtamet en yev pordzum en kaper@ chktrel kaghakakirt ashkharhi het. Yete nrank pokhen irenc koghmoroshum@ yev verjnakanapes Rusophile darnan, ham@ durs kga.

  4. […] Libertarian-Socialist Movement responds to what it calls “Nazi discourses” in Armenian politics. Nathan […]

  5. It takes less mental effort to condemn than to think. — Emman Goldman

  6. I was larger than walking. shakira naked Were two hundred feet over the.

  7. ewomaqo said

    christina aguilera dirrty

  8. bisexual orgies

  9. fetish said

    Hes so we almost painfully, downher back taking nylon stocking sex it except for some mirrors.

  10. messy facial

  11. dqonipy said

    glass dildo

  12. teenie said

    It will last much as she gradually teenie sex site came to do it.

  13. sluts said

    Were acting really strange. Try and then hot asian slut turnedagain letting it.

  14. Cheap levitra works in much the same way as Sildenafil Citrate, but is much faster, lasting up to 36 hours vagra prescriptions ! For viagra pills fast delivery Usa. Save your time-buy tadalafil tabs online. Fast to get sexual activity pills online.. Find out more about cialis at the famouse ciallis pill site

  15. bbizbor said

    Поставте антиспам

  16. Cheap levitra the prescription erectile dysfunction (ED) tablet clinically proven to both work fast (in as little as 30 minutes for some men) and work up to 36 hours vaiagra generic mexico . For levitra vardenafil very fast delivery worldwide.. No prescription required – buy cheap cialis pills on line… Fast to get ed treatment pills online. Find out more about cheap cialis at the online vigara sildenafil citrate site

  17. wilmaret said

    Cialis the prescription erectile dysfunction (ED) tablet clinically proven to both work fast (in as little as 30 minutes for some men) and work up to 36 hours ciallis versus levitra … For cialis natural fast delivery Usa.. Save your time – buy ed pills … Fast to get viagra pills online… Find out more about viagra at the famouse viagara site

  18. nannatul said

    Levitra the prescription erectile dysfunction (ED) tablet clinically proven to both work fast (in as little as 30 minutes for some men) and work up to 36 hours cialias kamagra … For levitra 20mg fast delivery Europe.. Save your money-buy cheap cialis tabs now.. Easy to get ed pills online.. Find out more about levitra at the famouse cealis discount uk site…

  19. vilmaram said

    Cheap viagra works in much the same way as Sildenafil Citrate, but is much faster, lasting up to 36 hours vigara online shop … For cialis order cheap fast delivery Europe.. Save your money buy ed pill now.. Easy to get levitra pills online.. Find out more about ed at the famouse viagera blue pill site.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: